Italian Restaurants In Nottingham

Scarlett Welch's profile picture
By Scarlett Welch Junior Editor, DesignMyNight Food, drink and events expert with 4 years in editorial and Media & Journalism MA. Last updated on 24th February 2026

Ahhh Italian food. From classic bowls of creamy carbonara to gorgeous charcuterie spreads and sourdough slices of pizza, the cuisine really is a carb lover's dream. And lucky for you, we've rounded up the best Italian restaurants in Nottingham, so you can visit everything from quirky pubs fronting doughy delights to fine dining city centre haunts.




Pizza Pilgrims Nottingham

The Quick Pilgrimage £25 per person and 3 other offers

Found in the heart of the city, Pizza Pilgrims is a welcoming restaurant serving authentically prepared Neapolitan pizzas, made using traditional techniques and Italian ingredients. Expect toppings like burrata, creamed spinach and pepperoni with hot honey, as well as small plates like cacio e pepe balls or garlic bread sharers.

There's a cracking cocktail menu to boot, all affordably priced. As for the interiors, expect all sorts of colourful, quirky decor, with a cool private dining space upstairs.

Gusto Italian - Nottingham

Sign up to our complimentary Gold Club today and enjoy £10 off your next visit, 5% cashback every time you dine, a round of drinks on us on your birthday, exclusive invites to VIP events, and more!

If you're on the hunt for the best Italian restaurants in Nottingham city centre, check out Gusto. The venue fronts quite the selection of pasta, from veggie bucatini to classic lasagna. For something interactive, try the Chef's Table experience, where you can have a go at pizza-making. 

Sinatra's

Steamed mussels? Garlic bread? Crispy calamari? Yes, yes, and yes. Sinatra's is one of the best places for Italian tapas in Nottingham, whether you're in the mood for a few plates to share or a huge spaghetti bolognese all to yourself.